In an era where every penny counts amid soaring living costs and squeezed public finances, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) is once again under fire for what can only be described as a monumental squander of taxpayer money. The tax authority has unveiled plans to splash out nearly £500,000 on a fancy digital platform for pre-recorded video interviews in its recruitment drive. Yes, you read that right—half a million quid for a tool that lets job hopefuls hit "record" from their living rooms. As HMRC grapples with backlogs and public distrust, this procurement reeks of bureaucratic excess. In this deep dive, we eviscerate HMRC's latest IT folly, exposing why it's a colossal waste and how it fits into the agency's sorry history of digital disasters.
What Exactly is HMRC's Video Interview Platform Plan?
Picture this: You're applying for a desk job at HMRC, and instead of a quick Zoom chat, you're funnelled into a bespoke system where you pre-record answers to scripted questions. That's the gist of HMRC's shiny new procurement notice, published on October 7, 2025, via the UK government's Find a Tender service. The contract? A three-year deal kicking off March 1, 2026, and running until February 28, 2029, with an estimated value of £450,000 (excluding VAT)—that's £540,000 including the dreaded tax on top.
The platform promises a laundry list of features: creating and distributing pre-recorded interview questions, secure candidate recording, user-friendly interfaces for everyone from recruiters to applicants, template management, invitation tracking, progress monitoring, and slick reporting tools. It must be "resilient, scalable, and adaptable" for multiple campaigns, all while ticking boxes for security, accessibility, and data protection under UK laws. HMRC is running this through a Competitive Flexible Procedure on their SAP Ariba portal, with bids opening next month and a decision by February 2026.
On paper, it sounds innovative. In reality? It's a gold-plated gimmick when free tools like Microsoft Teams or Google Meet could handle 90% of this for peanuts. Why fork out half a million when off-the-shelf solutions exist? This isn't rocket science—it's recruitment basics dressed up as cutting-edge tech, all at the expense of the very taxpayers HMRC is meant to serve.
The Shocking Cost Breakdown: Half a Million for What?
Let's break down this eye-watering spend. Over three years, that's roughly £150,000 annually for a system that's essentially a glorified video uploader with admin bells and whistles. HMRC admits the figure is an "estimate" based on "programme delivery," but history tells us these numbers balloon. Remember, this is public money—your income tax, VAT on your groceries, National Insurance from your paycheque—diverted to a vendor who'll pocket the lot for software that's already commoditised.
Critics are piling on, calling it tone-deaf. With HMRC facing a £1.6 billion shortfall in digital modernisation funding as per the latest Spending Review, prioritising a recruitment toy over core services like timely tax refunds or fraud crackdowns is baffling. And let's not forget the opportunity cost: That £500k could fund thousands of hours of staff training or bolster understaffed helplines drowning in calls.
Why This is Peak Bureaucratic Waste: Free Alternatives Abound
Here's the evisceration: This procurement isn't just expensive—it's embarrassingly redundant. Platforms like HireVue, Spark Hire, or even free tiers of Vidyard offer pre-recorded video interviewing out of the box, often for under £10,000 a year for mid-sized orgs. HMRC could integrate these with existing tools like their SAP ecosystem without a custom build. Need templates and tracking? Excel and Google Forms handle that for zero cost.
HMRC's insistence on a "tailor-made" solution smacks of the classic public sector trap: Over-specifying requirements to justify the spend, then watching costs spiral. Security and accessibility? Vital, sure—but these are standard in modern SaaS tools, compliant with GDPR and WCAG without needing a bespoke £450k overhaul. It's as if HMRC recruiters can't be trusted with a webcam unless it's wrapped in proprietary code. This isn't innovation; it's inertia, propping up consultants and vendors while applicants fiddle with glitchy uploads on their smartphones.
In a post-pandemic world where remote interviews are the norm, HMRC's move feels like reinventing the wheel with taxpayer grease. Small businesses and startups manage this daily without breaking the bank—why can't the UK's tax giant?
HMRC's Hall of Shame: A Legacy of IT Catastrophes
This video platform isn't an isolated blunder; it's the latest chapter in HMRC's epic saga of IT failures and wasteful spending. Take Making Tax Digital (MTD), the flagship digital tax overhaul launched in 2016. Billed at £226 million, it ballooned to over £1.3 billion by 2023, plagued by delays, bugs, and "making tax difficult" for small businesses, as slammed by Parliament's Public Accounts Committee. Businesses wasted hours on faulty software, while HMRC's own systems crumbled under the load.
Flash back to 2012: HMRC's £1 billion Connect tax fraud detection project missed "virtually all delivery dates," per a National Audit Office report, wasting millions on vapourware that barely dented evasion. Fast-forward to legacy IT woes—HMRC still burns cash maintaining dinosaur systems, with COVID-era extras alone hitting £53 million in 2020. And don't get us started on the shared services fiasco, rated "red" by watchdogs for budget blowouts and unachievable goals.
These aren't one-offs. Whitehall's IT graveyard is littered with HMRC's corpses: Overspends, under-deliveries, and a culture that rewards failure with more funding. The 2025 Spending Review tossed another £1.6 billion at HMRC's digital desk, yet here we are, £500k lighter on recruitment gimmicks. It's a vicious cycle: Promise transformation, deliver trash, rinse, repeat—all on the public's dime.
The Real Victims: Hardworking Taxpayers Bearing the Brunt
Every pound HMRC wastes is a pound stolen from essential services. That £500k could hire 10 full-time advisors to clear the 8 million-case backlog, or fund anti-fraud tech that actually works. Instead, it's funnelled to a vendor for a platform few will use efficiently. Public trust in HMRC is already in the toilet—accusations of "degrading services as policy" abound, with helplines slashed and digital mandates alienating vulnerable taxpayers.
This isn't abstract; it's personal. Families struggling with energy bills see their taxes vanish into bureaucratic black holes, widening inequality while HMRC pats itself on the back for "modernisation." In an age of austerity for the masses, such profligacy demands outrage.
Time to Hold HMRC Accountable: Demand Better from Your Tax Watchdog
HMRC's £500,000 video interview splurge is the poster child for government waste: Unnecessary, overpriced, and insultingly out of touch. As bids roll in next month, it's imperative MPs, watchdogs, and taxpayers raise hell. Petition your MP, bombard the National Audit Office, and amplify this scandal—because silence equals complicity.
Enough is enough. HMRC exists to collect taxes efficiently, not squander them on shiny distractions. Until accountability reigns, every procurement notice is a potential heist. Stay vigilant, Britain—your money depends on it.
Tax does have to be taxing.
HMRC Is Shite (www.hmrcisshite.com), also available via the domain www.hmrconline.com, is brought to you by www.kenfrost.com "The Living Brand"
No comments:
Post a Comment