Monday 20 November 2023

HICBC Eviscerated by Retired Tax Tribunal Judge

Richard Thomas's views on the matter in full here.

My humble views are as follows:

In the grand tapestry of government policies, the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) stands out as a particularly flawed and ineffective measure. Introduced in 2013, the HICBC was intended to claw back Child Benefit from high-earning households, ostensibly to ensure a fairer distribution of taxpayer funds. However, its implementation has been plagued by administrative complexities, a lack of transparency, and an overall failure to achieve its stated goals. Let's delve into the reasons why the HICBC has fallen short and explore the implications of its failure.

Administrative Complexity: A Bureaucratic Labyrinth

The HICBC's administrative framework is a tangled mess, leaving taxpayers and tax professionals alike bewildered and frustrated. The rules governing the charge are convoluted, with multiple thresholds, exemptions, and calculations that make it challenging to determine liability. This complexity has led to a surge in errors, both by taxpayers and by Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs (HMRC), resulting in a deluge of appeals and penalty charges.

Lack of Transparency: Shrouded in Secrecy

The HICBC operates in a shroud of secrecy, with HMRC providing limited guidance and support to taxpayers. The department's website is a treasure trove of confusing jargon and intricate details, leaving individuals struggling to decipher their obligations. This lack of transparency has fueled mistrust and resentment among taxpayers, who feel unfairly targeted and inadequately informed.

Failure to Achieve Its Goals: Missing the Mark

The HICBC's primary objective was to reduce the overall cost of Child Benefit while ensuring that high-income households contributed their fair share. However, it has failed to achieve either of these goals. The charge has had a negligible impact on reducing Child Benefit expenditure, and many high-income households have found ways to circumvent the charge altogether. As a result, the HICBC has become an ineffective and unfair burden on a select group of taxpayers.

The Ripple Effects of Failure: A Broader Impact

The HICBC's failure has far-reaching consequences beyond its immediate impact on taxpayers. It has eroded public trust in government institutions, fueling perceptions of inefficiency and unfairness. The charge has also created a significant administrative burden for HMRC, diverting resources away from other essential tasks. Moreover, the HICBC has damaged the reputation of the Child Benefit system, which is designed to support families and children.

Conclusion: A Call for Change

The HICBC stands as a testament to the pitfalls of poorly conceived and poorly implemented policies. Its administrative complexity, lack of transparency, and failure to achieve its goals have made it a resounding failure. The government must acknowledge these shortcomings and take decisive action to address them. This may involve simplifying the charge's rules, providing clearer guidance to taxpayers, and exploring alternative methods of achieving its intended objectives. Until such changes are made, the HICBC will remain a flawed and ineffective policy, casting a shadow over the Child Benefit system and public trust in government.

Tax does have to be taxing.

Tax Investigation Insurance

Market leading tax fee protection insurance for businesses, sole traders and individuals. Protect yourself from accountancy fees in the event of an HMRC enquiry.

Having a Solar Protect Tax Investigation Insurance policy at your disposal means that should you be one of the many 1000's of businesses or individuals that are selected by HMRC each year to look into your tax affairs your own accountant (your tax return agent) can get on and defend you robustly.

You have the peace of mind knowing that your accountant's (your tax return agent) fees will be paid by the insurance without any Excess for you to find.

Tax Investigation Insurance is an insurance policy that will fully reimburse your accountant's (your tax return agent) fees up to £100,000 if you are subject to enquiry by or dispute with HMRC.

A Solar Protect policy will enable your accountant (your tax return agent) to:

  • Deal with any correspondence from HMRC
  • Attend any meeting with HMRC
  • Appeal to the First-tier Tribunal or Upper Tribunal
  • Having the security of knowing that fees will be met in full will enable your Accountant (your tax return agent) to defend your position robustly

Please click here for details.

HMRC Is Shite (, also available via the domain, is brought to you by "The Living Brand"


  1. This is absolutely damming from a professional of such stature.

    Of course, accountants and awake HMRC employees already know that the department is riven with unfairness and inefficiency.

    1. The Loan Charge Scandal

    2. The Staff Bullying Culture

    These are just two of the numerous issues that long ago eroded and smashed public confidence in this failed institution.

    It's decline was accelerated by Homer and the job was completed by the unintelligent 'Sir' Jonny Thompson.

    Harra has done and will do nothing to turn it around - another 'yes person' awaiting his knighthood.

    No wonder the country is in such a mess.

  2. These rats are sick in the head !!!